null

Where Good Ideas Come From

May 17, 2023
Bestselling author Steven Johnson will discuss the secrets behind unusually creative individuals and organizations.

00:04 Please welcome best selling author and host of the PBS's six part series, How We Got to Now. Stephen Johnson. Uh, good morning, everyone. What a treat to be all together in a shared space like this. I think this is the largest audience I've spoken to in 3 or 4 years, which is really exciting in part because one of the things I want to talk to you about today is the importance of gathering in

00:37 a shared physical space and the ideas that inevitably come out of those kinds of encounters. So it's really terrific to be up here talking to you. As you can see, I've written a number of books over the years and I've had the great opportunity to pursue a number of different topics in those books. So I've written about the invention of robotics and I've written about 18th century chemistry and I've written about cholera, which I will not talk about. You'll be happy to know today and video games and a whole range of different things.

01:07 But there's a shared theme that runs through all of these books and the TV shows that I've done, and that is a kind of fascination I've always had with new ideas and how they come in the world with innovation and creativity. And the people and the organizations and the places and the moments in history that have proved to be unusually generative in their ability to create ideas that end up really transforming society in the world.

01:39 That's the kind of core thread that runs through everything that I've done over the course of my career. And so what I wanted to do today is really to tell you some stories, drawing from a number of these different books and projects, stories that I think embody the the patterns that I've seen in the lives and careers of unusually innovative people and organizations through history. This is going to be kind of a long view going back several hundred years and and going up to the very recent, recent past.

02:11 And one of the first things that I learned when I started to kind of explore this history is that in a funny sense, the language we use to describe innovation and creativity is all wrong. We have an enormous number of metaphors that describe a kind of a single moment of of clarity when an idea pops into our head and everything changes. We just think of the words that we have, how much language we have for this. We have eureka moments, aha moments, light bulb moments, epiphanies.

02:46 I mean, there's just an incredibly rich vocabulary to describe this, this sense, you know, and I understand from a storytelling perspective why this is appealing. There's something satisfying about a story where a brilliant idea just emerges out of nowhere. You know, the apple falls from the tree and, oh, we have a theory of gravity, right? There's something kind of immediately arresting about telling the story that way. But in all the research that I've done, what I've found again and again and again is that the eureka moment is almost always

03:17 a myth. That truly transformative ideas do not just pop into people's minds, they emerge slowly, almost in a kind of an evolutionary process that takes months, sometimes years, sometimes more than a decade. They come into the world not as a fully formed idea, but rather as a hunch. What I called in my book, where good ideas come from the slow hunch, and they stay in that state for a long period of time. There a hint of possibility, a sense that there's something interesting worth exploring.

03:49 But it's not at all clear in that initial glimpse of what their ultimate promise is. And I think this is not just a kind of philosophical point. It's important for all of us who are thinking about how to be more innovative in our jobs and our organizations is to figure out ways to cultivate these hunches, to give them the time they need to evolve rather than just betting everything on Eureka moments. We could spend all of our time here this morning running through examples of the slow hunch. But. But I'll give you one case study, maybe my favorite example of it,

04:20 which is visible and in this image is here. I don't know if you can read that handwriting. It says, this machine is a server. Do not power it down. And this little sticker, the giveaway here is that it says CERN in the upper left hand corner there. This little sticker was on the original worldwide web server, which was invented by Tim Berners-Lee at the famous Swiss physics lab CERN in

04:53 the 1980s. This sticker was on the original worldwide web server back when the entire web was running on one computer. Right. So you could trip over the power cord and the entire web would have gone down at that point. That's the way it was back then. And the story of how Berners-Lee came up with this idea, which if you think about it, is probably with the invention of the Internet itself. Before that, one of the two most important world transforming ideas of the late 20th century. I mean, everything changed because of this idea.

05:25 And it is a classic case of the slow hunch at work. So Berners-Lee shows up at CERN as a young programmer in the early 1980s, and he's almost immediately overwhelmed by the sheer kind of magnitude of the geniuses all around him, right? He's working among these Nobel laureates or future Nobel laureates who are inventing all these things and large colliders and all these extraordinary physics experiments. And so he's kind of intimidated and purely for himself, just as almost like a hobby,

05:57 he decides to create a little application to help him keep track of all the people he's meeting and all the projects that people are working on. He calls this little program Inquire After this wonderful Victorian encyclopedia he had read when he was growing up, which was had a great Victorian name inquire within upon everything, which would have been a good name for Google. And so he he develops this program called Inquire. And every time he meets somebody new he creates a little entry for that person.

06:31 And if that person is collaborating on a project, he creates another entry for that person and he creates a link connecting those two. And if those two write a paper, he creates an entry for the paper connecting the two, the two authors. So he builds a little hypertext system just just to build a kind of mental map of of his colleagues. And he does that, maintains this for a couple of years. And then in the mid 80s he starts working on a slightly more advanced version of it, which he briefly calls Tangle. The World Wide Web was almost called tangle.

07:03 And it wasn't until the late 80s when he started working on a kind of a third iteration of it, that he began to think that maybe he was on to something big. And that led to what I think of as one of the great moments in the history of office politics where he had to go into supervisors and have that awkward conversation that I'm sure you've all had where he says, I believe I may have invented a global communications medium in my spare time, and I would like to focus on this on this full time now, instead of all the stupid stuff you have me doing.

07:33 And fortunately, they let him do it. And fortunately they released it as an open standard for the world to to build on, which is an important part of the story. And now we live in the world that has been absolutely transformed by this idea. So it really took, if you think about it, it took about 5 or 6 years for the idea to to go from this hint of its ultimate promise to something that really mattered. And in fact, it took another five years for the rest of the world to catch up to it. So it was really a ten year incubation period for this slow hunch.

08:04 And I think part of the lesson here is that not just that Berners-Lee was was brilliant, which he undoubtedly was, but that he had the tenacity and the persistence to keep that idea alive over such a long period of time, because your hunches are the first things that you forget, right? You have more immediate pressing issues you have to work on. You have deliverables for this quarter, you have your own objectives that you know you need to get done. And so hunches get left behind and and then you forget about them. And it's often picking up an idea that you had 2

08:36 or 3 years ago that didn't fully make sense in 2020. But suddenly in 2023, because of something that has happened or because some other change in the world or some new technology or some new collaborator you have, and we'll talk more about that. The idea does make sense. It's part of this is just write your hunches down and go back and revisit them over time. Don't just let them kind of disappear into the into the kind of lost memories in your mind.

09:07 The other thing that I've learned from looking at this history is that in addition to the kind of vocabulary problem we have for understandable reasons, again, we tend to tell these histories of innovation in terms of the winners and in terms of the products that broke out and succeeded. But the history of innovation is also littered with all these examples of people who who did brilliant work, who got very close to a transformative idea, but for one reason or another, there was something in in a kind of conceptual blind spot that kept them from

09:42 reaching the full promise of the idea that they were working on. There was something that when you look back on it with hindsight, you say, Well, that was obvious. Of course you should have seen that. But at the time something kept them from seeing it. And I think this history is worth. Spending some time on for a couple of reasons. One, it's part of what happened, and we should understand if we're interested in the history of ideas, we should we should understand it. But more importantly, all of us, I guarantee you, are walking around with some kind of conceptual blind spot right now that in 3

10:12 or 4 years we're going to be like, Oh, why didn't I see that new technology coming? Why didn't I anticipate this possibility here, this potential use of the technology I'm developing or the idea I'm developing or this new product? And so understanding why people get locked into these blind spots I think is really instructive. Now, in the book and TV series we did how we Got to Now, we had an episode on the history of sound technology, and there's a story we told in that that is kind of one of the sadder stories that I've told, but I think it's illustrative and it's a story about a French inventor in

10:47 the middle of the 19th century at a great French name, Edward Lyon, Scott de Martinville. I'll just call him Scott. And Scott invented. In the early 1850s a device for recording audio. He called it the phonograph, the self righting of sound. And it was this brilliant device that took in sound waves in the upper left hand corner. There you can see into this vessel the it would cause the outer boundaries of

11:19 the vessel to vibrate, which would pass those vibrations down to this little thin pig's bristle at the end, which would then etch the shape of the sound wave onto this rotating cylinder. And then you could unfurl a piece of paper and you would see the sound wave there for the first time. No one had ever seen this before. The shape of the sound inscribed on this paper. He called it a diagram, the actual recording. Now, if you know anything about the history of audio, you are probably thinking to yourself, Well, wait a second. Thomas Edison invented the phonograph in the 1870s.

11:54 That's the famous breakthrough in audio history. Why are we talking about this French guy who's no one's ever heard of? And there's a reason why we've never heard of Edward Lyon, Scott de Martinville, besides this complicated name. And that is because there was one missing feature in this product, despite the fact that he was 20 years ahead of Thomas Edison. If you're 20 years ahead of Edison, almost a full generation ahead of Edison, you know you're doing something right. But Scott suffered from a crucial blind spot.

12:26 And that blind spot was that this product did not include playback. There was no way to listen to the audio you had recorded. This turns out to be among people purchasing audio equipment, a very highly sought after feature. When they released the iPod, it wasn't enough to know that you had a thousand songs in your pocket. You really needed to hear those songs. That's part of the the sales pitch here.

12:56 So this didn't work because it didn't have playback. It was just recording the audio. And what I love about this story, what's so fascinating about this story is that playback was so thoroughly in Scott's blind spot that it never even occurred to him. It wasn't like he was trying to add playback to this device. It just wasn't even in his field of vision. It wasn't something he'd even considered. Which raises the question of what the heck was he thinking? Like, what was what was the point of this device?

13:26 And this is where it gets really interesting. I think Scott was basically trained as a stenographer. He'd learned how to take dictation and he'd seen how human beings could learn the kind of the language of shorthand and could listen to someone talking in real time. And they could put a bunch of scribbles on a piece of paper. And if you understood the language of shorthand, you could then turn those scribbles back into intelligible words and sentences. And so he thought that if he could capture the the image of the sound waves of people speaking.

13:57 The people would learn how to read those sound waves and would be able to turn them back into once they learned that language into words and sentences. So he was basically building an auto dictation machine. Which, if you think about it, was actually a pretty good bet, right? Human beings have been deciphering scribbles on pieces of paper since the invention of the alphabet, So it seemed kind of likely. Unfortunately, no human being can do this. We can't read soundwaves. It's just something we can't do. Years later, about a century later,

14:27 a bunch of researchers found some of these funny anagrams that that Scott had recorded, and they fed them into a computer and had the computer then convert the soundwaves back into audio. And when they when they first played them, they thought they heard the sound of a little girl singing Eau Claire de la Lune, the French song, until they realized they were actually playing at kind of twice the playback speed. And when they slowed it down, they realized it was Scott himself from the grave singing this song.

14:57 You know, 100 years later, he finally got playback for his device. Now it's too late for him. He died kind of penniless and forgotten. But the point here is that he was so trapped in one particular way of thinking about the technology, he was stuck with one governing metaphor for what this machine was good for. It was going to be a dictation machine. And I can't help but think that one of his key problems was that he was working alone

15:28 fundamentally on this. That that enabled me to be kind of stuck in this one kind of conceptual framework in thinking about what he was inventing and if he'd perhaps had a partner, a collaborator who might have suggested some other uses for it, who was attacking the problem from a different angle. He might well have seen around that blind spot and invented the phonograph 20 years before Edison, for instance. I often think if he'd been working with a musician instead of just working inside of this stenography metaphor,

16:01 at some point the musician might have said, Listen, Edward, I think this is a fantastic invention, but it would be really great if I could play my violin and we could record it and then I could hear it again. That might have been enough. And that leads to one of the most important themes that that goes throughout my work, which is one of the reasons why it's so fantastic to be in a shared space here with so many people coming from so many different places and coming from different fields of work, different problems that they're trying to wrestle with, which is that almost every great idea, transformative idea,

16:35 comes not just out of an individual mind, but out of an out of a network. And good ideas. I talk about this as the idea of liquid networks environments where there's just a certain kind of flow of information where ideas are free to move from kind of mind to mind, and particularly where ideas are free to move from one discipline to another or from one kind of way of thinking to another. So many great ideas in history have come when an idea crosses a conceptual border.

17:08 Someone invents an idea in a certain field or a certain scientific discipline or at a or in the creative fields. And that idea does well in that particular milieu, but someone else takes part of that idea and ports it over into another domain where it unlocks a new space of possibility. And so when we're in environments that have this kind of network fluidity to them. Where people are sharing, kind of making surprising, serendipitous connections. Those are incredibly generative spaces like the history of of great ideas is not about people sitting in isolation,

17:41 trying to think a big thought. It's about people collaborating across borders. And we could talk about spaces and we're really fascinated by the physical spaces that enable that kind of creativity. And again, there are many, many examples of them. We could spend all our time talking about this part of the the talk as well. But I'll give you one, which I've just been obsessed with. I've written about it in like five of my books. I keep coming back to it because it's such an important part of our history that is underappreciated. And it's one of the great idea spaces of of the last 3 or 400 years,

18:15 and that is the 18th century coffee house. If you had to put a point on the map, if you had to answer the question, where did the Enlightenment happen? Like what kind of room did the Enlightenment happen in the great flowering of ideas and the early 1700s that really changed the world at so many different ways ideas in philosophy and in science and politics and technology. So many ideas flourished in this period.

18:45 If you had to figure out where what space drove that revolution, it would not be a university lecture hall. It would not be a corporate headquarters or an R&D lab. It was more than anything else, the coffee house. Almost every important idea from that period, particularly in England, in the United States or the colonies at that point has a coffee house at some point in the origin story of that idea.

19:18 The original stock markets evolved in coffee houses. Lloyd's of London, the Great Insurance Company, was originally Lloyd's coffee house. It was a place where local investors, investors and ship captains would gather and have coffee, and they started thinking about using this new probability math that had developed to take a little of the risk out of the shipping business that was flourishing. The first magazines emerged out of coffeehouses. The first public museums came out of people displaying interesting kind of novelties

19:50 in coffeehouses. In that period, again and again and again, we see these extraordinary innovations coming out of this space. So the question is why? What was it about this space that made it so magical? What can we learn from it? Part of the answer, which is just part of the history, I don't know what you can do. What you will with this is the simple fact that people were drinking coffee and tea because until about 1650, 1660,

20:20 when coffee and tea first emerged in in Europe and Northern Europe, up until that point, the default beverage of choice for the entire population was alcohol. Right? People would wake up and they would have beer for breakfast and beer through the morning on the job. They would have a little wine at lunch. There were these huge gin epidemics that happened in the early 1600s where people just went insane drinking gin all day long. So we don't teach this in the history books, perhaps for understandable reasons, but until the early 1700s, the kind of background state of the entire Europe,

20:55 European population was just kind of mild to heavy intoxication. That was just the reality of life. And then all of a sudden, this new craze for caffeine emerges and the entire population switches from drinking a depressant all day long to drinking a stimulant all day long. And lo and behold, there's this great flowering of intellectual industrial activity that suddenly happens. It sweeps across the continent. So it sounds like a joke, but there's a lot of scholarship on this. It's definitely part of what happened in the industrial Revolution.

21:27 Definitely needed caffeine because it reorganized people's time schedules. The factory time was so different from traditional, you know, kind of organic agrarian time that people had lived on. So coffee and caffeine are part of this story. But the point that I think is most relevant for us today is that this was also a multidisciplinary space. This was the liquid network of the 18th century. It was a space defined not by a single idea or a single corporate mission or

21:58 a single academic discipline, but a space where people would get together and have these open ended conversations where ideas could flow from mind to mind. And it was that open mindedness and that kind of playfulness that made it so powerful. Now, interestingly, shortly after these coffeehouses first appeared. Charles, who was then king of England, actually tried to ban them and issued a formal decree saying that these coffeehouses were distracting people from their lawful calling and affairs. They were, you know, being distracted.

22:32 They weren't going into their jobs and being productive. They were wasting time in these coffee houses . That ban lasted two weeks. Basically. People had already gotten their taste for coffee and they refused to put up with it. But the point here is that Charles the second was wrong. It looked like people were wasting their time, but in fact, it was an enormously productive space, precisely because it was a network space. It was a collaborative space. It was a space where surprising things could happen. And that actually extends beyond just gathering places like coffeehouses.

23:03 I think we should all think about like, what is the version of this in our own lives? What is the version of this in our own workspaces? How do we create that kind of coffeehouse like space in the spaces where we work and where we create? But the other lesson here is that that sense of play in that sense of open ended discovery and and delight has also driven innovation. What seemed like a distraction from your lawful calling

23:33 and affairs often turns out to be the seed of something really powerful and new and promising. And there's a shocking number of cases in the history of ideas that really changed the world. Where they began those ideas began as someone's kind of whimsical hobby. Something that was developed just. Just kind of for the fun of it ended up, over time, evolving into something that really changed everything in a in a more serious way.

24:04 Wrote a whole book called Wonderland about all these different innovations. One of them is is part of our recent history. These are a couple of MIT engineers in 1961 who had just received delivery of, at that point one of the most advanced computers in the world, the PDP one. Which was known as a microcomputer because it was only the size of a refrigerator instead of the size of an entire room. So it was micro.

24:35 But the other advantage the PDP one had in addition to this new processing power, was that it had a monitor attached, which was one of the first computers to have an actual screen. It was very grainy, not at all the kind of high resolution color monitors we expect today, but you could push pixels around the screen. And so these MIT grad students were trying to figure out what they could do to demonstrate the power of this new technology to get people to understand what made

25:05 it so revolutionary. And so they decided to create a game. Actually, the first proper video game that it's ever been created, there had been, you know, chess simulations and checkers simulations up until that point. But this is the first kind of native game that was that was ever created. They were science fiction fans. And so they decided to create a game with a with a kind of a space theme to it. And this became a game known as space war, space where it was if you're old enough to remember it,

25:35 it was it was a little bit like asteroids, the early arcade game. In fact, it turns out to be a kind of an ancestor of asteroids directly. You had a little spaceship that you can control. There was a star at the center of the screen. You could kind of drive your spaceship around. Another player controlled another spaceship and you wanted to avoid there was a there was some physics in the game. The star had a kind of gravitational field. You wanted to avoid getting kind of sucked into the star. I've actually played this game.

26:06 You can play it at the computer History Museum in Silicon Valley on an original PDP, one I brought about, I don't know, 7 or 8 years ago, I brought my then 15 year old son down and we played it against each other. He was not impressed with the graphics. It was no Grand Theft Auto, but it's playable. I mean, it's fun. There's something kind of innately just, you know, festive about it. And we were able to play this game that was, you know, at that point, 50 years old, I think. So this piece of software, which again,

26:40 was was a perfect example. It was literally play you think about the expense of this extraordinary microcomputer, all this some of the most powerful computational tools in the world at that point to take all of that and use it to play a game seemed incredibly frivolous, like a waste of time. Why would you ever do that? But space war ended up becoming arguably one of the most important pieces of software written in the 1960s.

27:10 It's circulated from computer science lab to computer science lab. People pass the code around and they would make little improvements to it. So they would fix bugs or they would make the physics engine a little bit more realistic, or they would add at some point somebody created an accurate map of the of the stars. And the sky is kind of a backdrop. They built a controller for it, kind of a predecessor of a modern game controller or joystick,

27:40 which was one of the first cases ever of someone using a physical device to manipulate an icon on the screen that represented their character. So in many ways, the predecessor of the mouse. It was one of the first examples of open source software that no one actually owned this software, but it was carried around, passed around from computer science lab to computer science lab getting improved and made more robust and faster over time.

28:10 So the development of, you know, just think of the significance of the open source software movement over the last 20 or 30 years. It partially began with this game, but one of the most important things that it did was that it changed people's perception of what computers were good for. In the late 1960s, Stuart Brand, who had started the Whole Earth Catalog classic West Coast, one of the founding members of the counterculture in the West Coast, was writing for Rolling Stone magazine at that time,

28:42 and he had gone to the computer science lab at Stanford, and he had seen all these people playing Spacewar. And he saw the kind of joy on their face and the laughter and the excitement about this game. And he thought, this doesn't make sense. This is not what computers are supposed to be for. Computers are supposed to be for the military, and they're supposed to be for big accounting firms and the IRS or something. But they're not supposed to be fun. But watching people play space where he began to realize that that was all wrong and that there was a different set of uses for the computer that might be possible.

29:13 So he wrote an article for Rolling Stone. He convened actually at Stanford, the first intergalactic Space War Olympics. They had a big space for competition, and he wrote about it for Rolling Stone. And the first word of that art, the first line of that article was Computers are coming to the people. And he coined an expression to capture this new vision of computing. And that expression was the personal computer.

29:45 So every time today when we use the shorthand phrase PC, it's an echo of the insight that Stuart Brand had watching people play Spacewar in 1969. And as it happens in the early 70s, when that Rolling Stone article came out, there was another young hippie in the Bay Area who read that article and thought that was really an inspiring thing. And so he went to work for Atari, the first video game company which was trying to develop Spacewar into an arcade game which became asteroids. And then he decided to start his own company.

30:20 And, well, that, as you probably guessed, was Steve Jobs. So there is a direct line connecting those early MIT grad students, inventing a game just for the fun of it and everything that came out of the PC revolution and Apple and all those breakthrough products that have changed our lives in so many different ways. So it's a reminder, I think, of of that sense of having retaining that sense of play and of having a lot of hobbies,

30:52 right, of doing things sometimes just for the love of it, just for the passion of it, and letting those ideas take you in surprising places. There is, however, a complicated side of this that I've written about more and more over the last couple of years. On the one hand, you can think of the invention of a whole industry like the personal computer business coming out of a just a game that seemed like a distraction when it first was imagined. You can think of that as a kind of unintended consequence.

31:23 But a positive, unintended consequence. This is not something that those engineers and grad students at MIT in 1961 were thinking about. But one of the things we know is that any time we unleash powerful new technologies in the world, they end up surprising us in one way or another. We can never fully anticipate how people are going to use the technology we're going to develop or what the secondary effects of that deployment are going to be. And I think one of our tasks now as a society and

31:53 as people who are doing innovative work is to think about that kind of longer term life cycle, really when we think about it in an environmental way, but also in a societal way of when we build things, how do they end up actually getting deployed and what are the what are the long term effects of that use? And sometimes I think that we've seen cases where the unintended consequences have been either negative or in some cases disastrous. And so part of the conceptual muscle we need to exercise is to be able to imagine those

32:26 downstream uses a little bit better and think about that longer life cycle. I just wrote a long article for the for the Time magazine about this gentleman here, really fascinating figure from the early 20th century. Thomas Midgley Jr. How many people have heard of Thomas Midgley Jr. Yeah. Interesting. Almost. Almost no one. This is the kind of thing that, again, I think should be in history books. Maybe that will change over time because he is, in a way, the patron saint of unintended consequences in the history of certainly the last century.

32:56 Mitchell was a brilliant chemist, kind of industrial chemist and engineer who worked for most of his life, kind of associated with General Motors. And in an extraordinary period of brilliant lab work between 1923 and 1928. He managed to invent almost single handedly both leaded gasoline and the CFCs that caused the hole in the ozone layer. Leaded gasoline in the form of ethanol,

33:26 which was a revolutionary breakthrough for the automobile industry. CFCs in the form of Freon, which was a revolutionary breakthrough for the refrigeration industry, both emerging technologies. There was huge demand for both innovations developed with the best of intentions, solving an urgent need at the time, making eliminating engine knock, making gas engines far more efficient, helping to spawn the kind of automobile revolution in the United States, and the new wave of interest in having home electric powered refrigeration refrigerators

33:59 that used a refrigerant that wasn't toxic or prone to explosions as the earlier ones had been. So these were breakthrough products, but leaded gasoline turned out to be one of the most profound, disastrous environmental toxins that we unleashed in the 20th century with untold, you know, affecting millions of lives around the world. And CFCs. If we had not intervened to to deal with them in the Montreal Protocol would have had

34:32 a catastrophic effect on all life on Earth. So no single human being, I think you could make the case, did more to damage the planet than Thomas Midgley Jr. And I don't mean to turn him into a villain, right? It was this was he was trying to solve a problem, and he did it in a very clever way. But there were these downstream consequences. And what's particularly, I think telling here is the difference between these two. So leaded gasoline was was a known threat on some level, right.

35:03 We knew that lead was toxic to humans. The argument was that there was so little of it being emitted to gas engines that human beings wouldn't be affected by it, but they at least knew that there was an issue here. Midgley himself had lead poisoning from helping to invent Ethyl when they first started manufacturing it at their at their plant, a number of the employees in the factory went insane. They began to see hallucinate insects swarming around them. They started calling the plant the house of butterflies

35:34 because people were going insane from lead poisoning. So there were some clues there that there was a problem. But here's the scary thing with the CFCs. There was no way to know that there was any connection between the chemical you were putting in your refrigerator and what was happening in the stratosphere in 1928. We didn't even understand anything significant about the ozone layer for another 20 or 30 years after that, it was literally a problem. The consequences. It was literally consequences that were not knowable to

36:07 science for another 30 years after Midgley originally came up with that innovation. And that's the part that I worry about, right? We have to figure out ways to get better at thinking long term about those consequences. Hopefully our scientific principles have advanced such that we can understand these things better. But I think all of us want to run those scenarios when we think about new things that we're unleashing in the world. Think about how this could go wrong. Force yourself. There's a there's a kind of cognitive exercise that the social psychologist Gary Kline talks about in a kind of corporate world,

36:40 which is this exercise called the pre mortem, that when you're right about to release something or you've made an important decision about a new product or a new technology run, this exercise, the pre mortem where you take the kind of key stakeholders and you ask everyone to to basically come up with a story. And the story is in 5 or 10 years, this thing we are about to do turns out to be a disaster for us as a business or for our customers or whatever it is. Tell the story of why that disaster happened.

37:12 And it turns out by forcing people to actually kind of imagine a narrative they end up seeing. More clearly flaws in the current plan or in the current product. And you can often then fix those flaws of those problems before you actually release it. If you just ask people what's wrong with this plan or what's wrong with this product, they'll often by that point, because of groupthink and confirmation bias, they'll be like, There's nothing wrong. But if you force them to run this exercise of the pre mortem, you actually end up discovering things that you wouldn't have otherwise discovered.

37:44 But I also think it's important not to be too pessimistic about these things. The part of the beauty and the power of great ideas is that they do unlock surprising downstream uses and and applications that we as inventors don't anticipate. And there's great power in that. So many great things in society have come out of that. That sense of the possibility space around a new idea expanding as it gets into

38:14 the hands of customers and they find new uses for these things. And so there's a certain level of openness that we want to encourage when we create and when we when we innovate. And I'll tell you just one final story that that I think embodies this, that it really brings together a a number of the different themes that we've talked about this morning. That's a story that starts in early October of 1957 when news reaches the United States that the Soviets have launched Sputnik, the first manmade satellite to orbit the planet.

38:47 And our story really begins at a place called the Applied Physics Lab in Laurel, Maryland, associated with Johns Hopkins. And Monday morning after this news is circulated through the United States. It's the headlines everywhere. The. Grad students at this APL Institute in Maryland. As you can imagine, they're just fascinated by this news, trying to figure out how the Russians did it, what it means,

39:18 and sitting there over lunch at the the equivalent of kind of the coffeehouse like space at the APL. There are these two young grad students and Guyer and wife and back, and they're chatting with their colleagues. And the two of them say to their older teachers and coworkers, they're going to say, hey, has anybody tried to listen for this thing? Like, it's probably sending out some kind of signal. We could probably pick it up.

39:48 And their colleagues are like, No, that's an interesting idea. No, we hadn't thought of that. And so they go back to, I think it's wife and box office or cubicle or wherever, and he actually has a little amplifier and antenna set up. He's kind of an expert in microwave reception. And so they start fooling around with it. And actually the Soviets have set Sputnik up. So it's sending a very clear signal because in part because they didn't want people to think they were faking it. And so after a couple of hours, they start picking up this little repetitive signal

40:19 on their just their office setup that they've kind of jerry rigged. They're right on their desk. And it's exciting. Right? This is their probably they think they're the first people in the United States to actually hear the first satellite ever sending a signal from, you know, low orbit. And so they decide to record it. So they bring out this like, bulky reel to reel tape recorder and they start recording them and marking the exact kind of timestamp for each little blip that they hear. And then they start noticing that there's slight frequency variation between

40:53 the signals they're picking up from the satellite and they start thinking, well, wait a second, if we measure that pretty quick precisely, we could probably figure out using the Doppler effect, how fast it's moving. That would be kind of cool. So they do those calculations and then after a while they start thinking, wait a second, we could probably look at the slope and the changes of those frequency variations to calculate when the satellite is closest to our antenna and when it's furthest away. And then they have to use the Univac computer, kind of a slightly older version compared to the PDP one that they had at the APL.

41:27 And using that, they ultimately, after a few weeks of work, they calculate the exact trajectory of the satellite around the planet. No point to this, right? There was no this was just for fun, really. This was just a hobby. This was just a hunch. But word of it gets out and the director of the APL, Frank McClure, eventually kind of calls them into his office and sits him down and says, Listen, I want to talk to you about that little interesting thing you did with Sputnik.

41:59 You all calculated an unknown location and trajectory in space, knowing a fixed point on the ground. And I want to know, could you do it the other way? If you if you knew the location in space, could you figure out the location on the ground? And they're like, Oh, that's interesting. And they went back and thought about it a little bit and they came back and they're like, Yeah, we could do that. It would be actually slightly easier. And McClure is like, Well, that's good news because you see, we have these new nuclear submarines that we're about to release,

42:30 and it turns out that if you want to get your missile to be aligned perfectly so that it lands right on its target, you really want to know where your submarine is. And we think we can put a bunch of these satellites up there and we can use them to calculate the exact locations of our submarines. And that, as you might have figured, is the birth of GPS. Now, GPS goes on to be used to track, you know, nuclear submarines and other military equipment for 20 years.

43:01 And then during the 80s, after the Korean Air disaster, Reagan effectively open sources that allows civilian aircraft and then eventually consumer technology to access the GPS system becomes this kind of open platform. And over time it gets deployed in all these extraordinary ways that we're certainly not in the mind of Geyer and wife. Back when they first started tinkering with trying to track the location of Sputnik. And in 1957, all of us probably in this room are walking around with

43:33 the device in our pockets that is talking to the descendants of those satellites, using the descendants of the technology that Gaia and wife stumbled across in Maryland in 1957. In fact, I almost guarantee you that someone in this room has probably many people has used all of that enormous technology to locate a nearby coffee house at some point in the last 24 hours. Right. And I think that that really shows you

44:03 the way in which sometimes you have these wonderful unintended consequences. Then when we allow these ideas to get into circulation and people to adopt them in new ways and push them in new directions, you think you're just exploring this idea of tracking this satellite for the fun of it, for the sheer kind of curiosity of it? And then you think you're helping the entire military potentially fight a war. And then it turns out 50 years later, you're just helping somebody find a soy latte. That is the march of technology over time. And I think that is what is so exciting about innovation is when you do it in

44:36 the right way, when you keep those liquid networks open, when you follow those hunches, you end up in places that even the most brilliant minds might not have anticipated. Chance favors the connected mind. Thank you very much. Thanks, everyone.

Related Videos
Watch the video Defense Program Readiness with Secure PLM Watch the video PLM Into the Factory Watch the video Integrated Lifecycle for A&D: Agile from Design to Delivery Watch the video PTC’s Aerospace & Defense Startup Program Watch the video Harnessing the Power of ALM: Innovating for the Future With Software-defined Products Watch the video Unlocking the Value of Windchill+ Watch the video Maximizing Efficiency with SaaS Solutions