Winning Product Designs: Low-Cost Metal 3D Printer [Interview]

Written By: Tiffany Bailey
  • 1/13/2017

A few months ago, PTC asked Creo users to submit their best work for a Product Design Contest. Submissions came from more than 60 countries and included objects like a wooden bike, a modular lamp, and jewelry inspired by sunflowers—all made with Creo product design software.

One of the finalists in the contest was experienced product designer, Mr. Muthalpandy Muthirulappan. He created a low-cost 3D printer that produces accurate and affordable prototypes. What’s better? Mr. Muthirulappan used 3D printing, or additive manufacturing, to troubleshoot his own printer design!

Mr. Muthirulappan, a finalist in the PTC Product Design Contest, designed a low-cost metal 3D printer.

Mr. Muthirulappan, a finalist in the PTC Product Design Contest, designed a low-cost metal 3D printer. “Low cost” refers to a range of printers priced from $1000-2500 USD.

Location: India

The design: Mr. Muthirulappan’s 3D printer has several notable features:

  • The size and length of the printer’s smooth rods can be changed. And, you can print prototypes larger than one cubic foot.
  • Operates for more than 24 hours of continuous printing.
  • Boasts a dual color print feature with perfect merging of layers.
  • Features precise dual nozzle printing that is compatible with free-flowing plastic or metal reinforced PLA filaments.

View of metal 3D printer model

The printer’s smooth rods are customizable. You can change the size and length.

The design challenges: Mr. Muthirulappan faced several challenges in creating his design:

  • Positional accuracy—to print high resolution prototypes consistently, Muthirulappan needed to make sure the nozzle tip was accurate and reliable along three axes.
  • Compact—Muthirulappan said he wanted the printer to be structurally (dimensionally) optimized—meaning he wanted the largest possible print area and the smallest possible printer size.
  • Lightweight—the design needed to be lightweight with minimum material stock in and around the components.
  • Easy to manufacture/assemble—the design needed to be compact, quick to manufacture, and easy to assemble.

The solutions: How did Mr. Muthirulappan overcome the 3D printer’s design challenges? He created a 3D printed prototype of his model, of course!

“I printed all of the main components, assembled it, and ran the machine to simulate the real printer,” he said. The prototype worked really well, but the printer’s vertical axis needed to be tweaked. Each axis has two smooth rods. However, he ended up adding a third rod along the vertical axis for additional support.

View of metal 3D printer

Mr. Muthirulappan said, “My 3D printer is designed to compensate for pitching, rolling, and yawing forces along the three axes.”

Why Creo? Mr. Muthirulappan raves about Creo, saying, “Solving any design problem is much easier and faster compared to other CAD software.” Here’s how it helped him:

  • Creo’s intuitive and interactive dialog boxes allowed him to focus on his design without having to memorize a certain sequence of the steps.
  • Annotation features let him pin-point the design intent by adding dynamic comments.
  • Placing GD&T symbols in the 3D model proved to be simple. Then, he could present those symbols in the 2D rendering automatically, without repeating the same task again in drafting.
  • Creo Parametric Style design environment made surface modeling tasks easy. He said, “Using just a few commands, I could create surface models with aesthetically pleasing and ergonomically standardized shapes.”

Creo 4.0 thoughts: Mr. Muthirulappan created his design using Creo 3.0, but said of the new release, “It seems like that many things in Creo 3.0 have been simplified in the Creo 4.0.”

Any advice for someone trying to create their own winning design with Creo? Mr. Muthirulappan said he learned a lot about how to improve his design when he analyzed the 3D printed model. So, his advice for other designers is simple: Create a 3D model that is 3D printable. Then, assemble the printed model as a functional prototype. Also, use Creo’s 3D print applications, which help analyze the model for any thin sections and continuity and tangency of the profiles.

Start Creating Winning Designs Today: Download Creo 4.0

No matter what you want to create, Creo 4.0 can help you develop stellar designs. Packed with hundreds of enhancements, this release is easier to use than ever, and includes tools for better 3D printing and model-based definition. Visit the Creo 4.0 page to find out more and start using it today.

Download Creo 4.0

  • CAD
  • Additive Manufacturing

About the Author

Tiffany Bailey

Tiffany Bailey is a content writer and editor for PTC. She has more than a decade of experience as a technical writer/editor. And over 5 years of experience writing about mechanical engineering, 3D CAD, and PDM. Her work spans topics like data migration and management, IoT and big data, IT security, additive manufacturing, simulation, and SaaS. She especially enjoys interviewing customers, product managers, and thought leaders to uncover new ideas and innovations.